Latest News

Richard Branson Declines Invitation To Debate Death Penalty With Shanmugam, Says It Will Lack Nuance

Richard Branson Declines Invitation To Debate With Shanmugam In Open Letter On 31 Oct

Singapore’s use of the death penalty has been under the spotlight locally and internationally.

One prominent critic of the policy recently had been British entrepreneur Richard Branson.

Earlier this month, the Ministry of Home Affairs (MHA) invited him to speak in a live televised debate with Law and Home Affairs Minister K Shanmugam.

On Monday (31 Oct), Mr Branson declined this invitation, saying it “reduces nuanced discourse to soundbites, turns serious debate into spectacle”.

Richard Branson declines debate, says it reduces nuanced discourse

In a blog post on Monday (31 Oct), Mr Branson penned an open letter to MHA and Mr Shanmugam.

Source: Virgin

He expressed that he has enormous respect for Singapore, Singaporeans, and everything the country has achieved.

But he has decided to decline the invitation to debate the death penalty in Singapore.

He explains that a television debate is limited in time and scope. Such a debate risks prioritising personalities over issues, which do not do the complexity of the death penalty any service.

Mr Branson said,

 

It reduces nuanced discourse to soundbites, turns serious debate into spectacle. I can’t imagine that is what you are looking for.

Singapore needs a constructive, lasting dialogue involving multiple stakeholders and a true commitment to transparency and evidence.

Urges Mr Shanmugam to engage Singaporean stakeholders

Mr Branson shared that he is not alone in raising Singapore’s “horribly wrong” use of the death penalty. The conversation requires local voices.

In the case of Singapore, global advocates like him were inspired by various people and organisations.

These advocates, lawyers, and journalists have experience, knowledge, and data on the topic.

Mr Branson said the brave thing for Mr Shanmugam would be to engage these Singaporean stakeholders.

He then mentions stakeholders Transformative Justice Collective, lawyer Mr M Ravi, Nagaenthran Dharmalingam’s lawyer, and regional group Anti-Death Penalty Asia Network.

These people should be treated as equals who are interested in Singapore’s progress. He said they deserve to be listened to, not ignored or harassed.

Abolition of death penalty not a Western concept

Singapore remains one of a small group of countries to impose the death penalty for drug offences.

In his opinion, it is a disproportionate and ineffective response to the world’s drug problems.

The abolition of the death penalty is not, as some would argue, a Western concept imposed on the rest of the world.

He stressed that it was an issue about universal human rights and humanity’s shared aspiration to advance equality, justice, dignity, and freedom for everyone.

He hoped that Singapore would realise that it was an inhumane, brutal practice. Instead of saving lives, it casts a dark shadow on Singapore’s reputation in the world.

Pointedly, he concluded by saying, “There is no evidence to support its continued existence. Just ask those in Singapore who know”.

Have news you must share? Get in touch with us via email at news@mustsharenews.com.

Featured image adapted from Virgin and K Shanmugam SC on Facebook.

Sabrina Seng

Sabrina is always facing some form of existential crisis but other than that, she's pretty chill.

Recent Posts

Passenger on US flight slammed for bringing Great Dane as ’emotional support’ dog

On the other hand, some said they'd prefer sitting next to a massive dog than…

23 Dec 2024, 10:12 am

Nearly 20 cats abandoned in Bedok flat filled with rubbish, some injured after jumping from windows

Some sustained injuries after jumping from windows, while others starved to death.

23 Dec 2024, 9:52 am

Continuous heavy traffic expected at S’pore-JB checkpoints till end of 2024: ICA

A record of more than 553,000 travellers crossed both checkpoints on 13 Dec.

22 Dec 2024, 7:25 pm

H5N1 poses ‘highest risk’ of becoming next pandemic, S’pore health authorities monitoring situation

There has been no year-end Covid-19 wave, as had been expected.

22 Dec 2024, 6:42 pm

Wagyu beef worth S$5,700 found in car entering JB from S’pore, M’sian driver arrested

The beef was imported without a veterinary health certificate and halal certification.

22 Dec 2024, 5:40 pm

Long queue forms at Jalan Besar Stadium for tickets to ASEAN Championship semi-final

One fan started queueing as early as 7am.

22 Dec 2024, 4:50 pm