International

Man in Mexico sues jeweller Cartier after brand refuses to hand over S$19K earrings listed at S$19

Man sues Cartier after brand refuses to hand over S$19,000 earrings listed at S$19

After chancing upon a pair of Cartier earrings listed for 237 Mexican pesos (S$19), Rogelio Villarreal seized the opportunity to snag the unbelievable deal.

However, this turned out to be an error as the luxurious accessory was actually worth a thousand times that price.

Promptly noticing the blunder, the French jeweller contacted Mr Villarreal to cancel the purchase.

Undeterred, he filed a case with Mexico’s consumer protection agency.

Ultimately, he emerged victorious as the brand eventually honoured the purchase, delivering the earrings for the price he had paid.

Source: @LordeDandy on X

Purchased 2 pairs of Cartier earrings after noticing low price

According to The New York Times, Mr Villarreal clicked on an Instagram ad by Cartier in December last year.

While browsing the online store, he saw a pair of diamond earrings with 18-carat rose-gold studded cuffs going for only 237 Mexican pesos (S$19).

In contrast, a gold necklace listed beside it carried a hefty price tag of 173,000 Mexican pesos (S$13,700).

Source: @LordeDandy on X

Instinctively, he seized the opportunity and purchased two pairs for his mother.

“Call me greedy, but I doubt any of you would have passed up the chance,” Mr Villarreal wrote on X.

 

Cartier amends price, customer files complaint & refuses to cancel order

Cartier soon realised its mistake and adjusted the price to 237,000 Mexican pesos (S$19,000).

The jeweller then contacted Mr Villarreal, requesting that he cancel his order and emphasising that the price he paid was incorrect.

Additionally, it offered to compensate him with gifts, including a bottle of Cartier Cuvée champagne and a leather product from the brand.

Mr Villarreal, however, stood his ground and did not cancel the order.

Instead, he took it upon himself to file a complaint with Mexico’s federal consumer protection agency.

During this process, he referenced a law that allows him to file a lawsuit if a company fails to adhere to the terms and conditions of his purchase.

Cartier fulfils order & delivers earrings

Mr Villarreal’s persistence paid off.

In a turn of events, he posted an update on X stating that Cartier had informed him it would fulfil his order.

On Friday (26 April), he received the two pairs of earrings, which he proudly unboxed in two TikTok videos.

Many netizens left Mr Villarreal congratulatory messages.

One X user also said that he had accomplished the dreams that many had: to defeat a million-dollar company.

Source: X

Also read: Man accidentally charged S$2,020.90 instead of S$20.90 for ribeye steak at Common Grill in Geylang

Have news you must share? Get in touch with us via email at news@mustsharenews.com.

Featured image adapted from @LordeDandy on X and @rovilljssr on TikTok.

Amber Ang

Amber is an unapologetic fangirl and a huge Swiftie.

Recent Posts

12-year-old boy in M’sia takes care of bedridden mother, changes her diapers & feeds her

The boy is an only child to the single mum.

16 Nov 2024, 11:39 am

Loose tyre flies off truck on Taiwan highway & crushes passing car, kills driver

Authorities had to use equipment to pry the vehicle open to free the man.

16 Nov 2024, 10:54 am

S’pore High Commission officer accused of child neglect in London, given a warning

The authorities have investigated and closed the incident with no follow-ups required, MFA said.

16 Nov 2024, 4:14 am

‘Fate extinguished his dream’: Motorcyclist killed in container truck accident in M’sia worked in S’pore

He crossed the border daily in hopes of buying a house for his family.

16 Nov 2024, 2:39 am

Wet weather to continue for rest of Nov, temperature could drop to 23°C on some days

On a few days, the thundery showers might extend into the night.

16 Nov 2024, 1:14 am

Priest discharged from hospital 6 days after Bukit Timah church stabbing, expresses gratitude for support

His church has urged parishioners to refrain from visiting him as he heals.

16 Nov 2024, 12:27 am