Couple Claims They Didn’t Understand S’pore Contact Tracer, Faces Charges For Withholding Info

Couple Who Gave False Info Claims They Didn’t Understand Contact Tracer

Rigorous contact tracing has helped tremendously in slowing the spread of Covid-19. But the success hinges on the public’s cooperation too.

So when a couple failed to provide accurate information to a contact tracer in 2020, it became a chargeable offence.

This is especially since one of them had tested positive for Covid-19.

Ms Shi Sha and her husband Mr Hu now face up to 6 month’s jail, a fine of $10,000, or both, for each offence.

Couple claims exchange with contact tracer was confusing

According to Channel News Asia (CNA), Ms Shi explained in court that she always had difficulties communicating with people in Singapore.

This reasoning prefaced her subsequent claim that any info she may have failed to accurately provide was due to miscommunication.

After her husband, who had arrived here from China in Jan 2020, was hospitalised, Ms Shi received a call from contact tracer Georgina Lim.

At that point in time, she allegedly didn’t know of her husband’s Covid-19 test results yet as nobody had informed her.

Ms Lim’s call, however, wasn’t to address this matter but to find out Mr Hu’s movements prior to his hospitalisation.

Source

 

Claiming that Ms Lim had spoken Mandarin sporadically in short phrases, Ms Shi explained that she found the conversation confusing. She even inferred that Mandarin isn’t Ms Lim’s mother tongue, an observation she confidently shared with the court.

Details from all parties ended up being different

One piece of information both parties disagreed on was Mr Hu’s mode of transportation from the airport after his arrival.

While Ms Lim shared Ms Shi’s alleged account of them queuing at a taxi stand, the latter disputed the statement, reports The Straits Times (ST).

Maintaining that she had not told Ms Lim about taking a taxi, Ms Shi said that she had hired a minibus instead.

CNA also noted that Ms Shi had given the wrong unit number for the apartment her family was staying in. For this, she reportedly explained that she had always assumed it to be #05-01, as it was the first unit along the corridor.

In total, Ms Shi faces 3 charges under the Infectious Diseases Act, including:

  • Withholding information
  • Giving false information
  • Failing to respond fully & truthfully to a health officer

Her husband, meanwhile, faces a charge for not informing an officer of the various places he had travelled to while infectious.

If convicted, each of them faces up to 6 months’ jail, up to a $10,000 fine, or both, for every offence.

Make a greater effort to understand each other

When procuring information as important as this, the details must be communicated clearly and truthfully.

While it seems unclear for now who may be to blame in this case, we hope this incident serves as a reminder for everyone to make a greater effort in understanding each other.

Perhaps if we all do so, we’ll be able to avoid major misunderstandings that may get out of hand like this.

Have news you must share? Get in touch with us via email at news@mustsharenews.com.

Featured image courtesy of sgsme.sg.

Iqmall Hayat

“Why waste time say lot word when few word do trick? ” -Kevin Malone

Recent Posts

Car brakes abruptly in front of bus along TPE, driver charged in court for dangerous driving

"The police do not condone such thuggish behaviour on the roads," they said.

17 Dec 2024, 12:08 am

Allianz withdraws offer to acquire Income, says it respects Govt’s decision to block deal

Singapore will "continue to remain an important market for Allianz", it said.

16 Dec 2024, 10:59 pm

Last week of 2024 will be drier, with below-average rainfall in 2nd half of Dec

The temperature will "slightly exceed" 34°C on a few days.

16 Dec 2024, 10:10 pm

Shanmugam and Tan See Leng to take legal action against Bloomberg over allegedly ‘libellous’ report on property deals

The ministers will be issuing Letters of Demand to the international media company.

16 Dec 2024, 6:54 pm

27-year-old electrician dies while helping restore electricity in flood victims’ home in Thailand

He was described as someone who liked helping others.

16 Dec 2024, 6:24 pm

Tourist fractures leg after being struck by train while trespassing on Taiwan railway tracks to take photos

The travel group she was with allegedly has a history of leading groups to illegally…

16 Dec 2024, 5:54 pm