Police & AGC Could Have Done Better In Parti Liyani Case, But Courts Were Fair: Shanmugam

Shanmugam Addresses Police Deficiencies In Parti Liyani Case

Over the course of the the past months, ex-helper Parti Liyani’s case gripped the nation.

On Wednesday (4 Nov), Law and Home Affairs Minister K Shanmugam addressed the case in Parliament.


During his Ministerial Statement, Mr Shanmugam talked about the lapses and breaches made by the police, as previously mentioned by the High Court.

However, he maintained that there was sufficient reason for Parti Liyani to be prosecuted for theft.

The courts also conducted her case fairly in light of the evidence provided, he said.

Deficient aspects of police investigations

During the parliament session on Wednesday (4 Nov), Mr Shanmugam addressed several aspects of the high-profile case.

Channel NewsAsia (CNA) reports that one major point brought up was the “deficient aspects” in relation to the police’s handling of the case.

These include the following:

  • delay before items were seized
  • poor quality of photos taken
  • inaccuracies in recording statements

Image for illustration purposes only

The gap of 5 weeks between the report being made by the Liews and police going down to the scene caused a “break” in the chain of custody over the allegedly stolen items.

Although this might not have affected the High Court’s decision in the end, Mr Shanmugam says the police should nonetheless have visited the home as soon as possible.

Acknowledging that this was a breach in police protocol and legal requirements, Mr Shanmugam shared that internal investigation are ongoing against the officers assigned to the case.

The police are also looking into how they can better ensure accountability and minimise such lapses.

However, Shanmugam seeks understanding over the heavy workload that officers have to deal with, due to manpower issues.

Inaccuracies in statements and poor photo quality

The police have also accepted the feedback that the photos they took were not up to standard.

Ms Parti was shown black-and-white photos of allegedly stolen items during the investigations. She was reportedly only shown coloured photos during her final statement.

Inaccuracies were also found in the process of recording Ms Parti’s statements, reported CNA.

The issues included providing a Bahasa Indonesia translator, the pace at which questions were asked, as well as one statement which was taken in the “wee hours of the morning”.

Responding to the concern about timing, the police cited difficulties such as the legal requirements to release a person under investigation within 48 hours.

Mr Shanmugam has also told the police to ensure that the person knows about the process in having an interpreter, as well as its purpose.

The accused should also be told that they can request for a interpreter at any time.

AGC developing guidelines for valuation of items

According to CNA, the Attorney-General’s Chambers (AGC) has identified areas of improvement through this case, such as the valuation of items that are the subject of property offences.

Currently, it is apparently the general practice to rely on the complainant’s assessment of value.

However, they are now looking into developing formal guidelines on this.

AGC decided there was sufficient evidence of theft

Despite the lapses, it was up to the AGC to access if the charges were appropriate.

Ultimately, Parti Liyani was charged as there was sufficient evidence of theft, and that it was in the public’s interest to prosecute her.


A major factor that led to this was the evidence put forth by the Liews when identifying the items.

In contrast, there were inconsistencies found in Ms Parti’s statements.

The AGC found that her claims lacked credibility. In one such statement, Ms Parti reportedly said that she had found iPhones as well as a luxury bag, sunglasses, and jewellery in the trash.

However, May, the daughter of Mr Liew, testified that she would never throw any jewellery in the trash.

This is in addition to the fact that Ms Parti confessed to taking 10-15 pieces of clothing belonging to her employer without their knowledge.

In the same statement, she apparently contradicted herself, saying that she “did not steal any other items”.

According to Mr Shanmugam, the theft claim was thus “very significant”.

Shanmugam says courts conducted Parti Liyani case fairly

Concluding his statement, Shanmugam said that there can be differing views on evidence and the law.

But the important point is not if the courts were right or wrong but whether the case was conducted fairly.

Despite the inadequacies throughout investigation, he believed the matter was “thoroughly ventilated and considered” by both the State Courts and the High Courts.

We’re also inclined to agree — fairness is a must in the court of law. Hopefully future cases will not fall victim to these lapses.

Have news you must share? Get in touch with us via email at

Featured image adapted from YouTube and Home.

Sabrina Seng

Sabrina is always facing some form of existential crisis but other than that, she's pretty chill.

Recent Posts

‘Of course, there is self-censorship’: Former editor Bertha Henson ‘flabbergasted’ by ST editor’s comments on censorship

"When you self-censor, you are saving your own skin... you don't want to get in…

29 Feb 2024, 9:11 pm

The Taylor ‘Swift Surge’: Fans face steeper hotel & airfare prices as S’pore concert approaches

Budget hotels are not so wallet-friendly anymore — at least for this period.

29 Feb 2024, 8:29 pm

Dignity Kitchen needs more than S$200K in donations to restore restaurant after 13 Feb fire

The blaze caused serious burns to both the interior and exterior of the restaurant.

29 Feb 2024, 6:24 pm

Mask-wearing no longer compulsory in S’pore clinics from 1 Mar: MOH

Masks will still be required in higher-risk healthcare settings such as inpatient wards and emergency…

29 Feb 2024, 6:13 pm

From slapstick comedian to bonafide actor: Mark Lee shines with visceral, heartfelt performance in ‘Money No Enough 3’

Lee has been diligently honing his acting chops over the decades.

29 Feb 2024, 6:03 pm

Rescheduled Sentosa Sky Lantern Festival event received no clearance, 11 complaints filed against organiser

SCDF said it is still following up with the organiser on the rescheduled event.

29 Feb 2024, 6:02 pm