Louis Ng Plans To Talk About Secondhand Smoke In Flats, Hopes To Protect Residents’ Health

MP Louis Ng Will File Motion To Talk About Protection From Secondhand Smoke In HDB Flats

Many a family will have experienced the problem of a neighbour’s cigarette smoke drifting into their household.

The prevalence of smoke entering other households also increased during the ‘Circuit Breaker’, as more people started working from home, according to the National Environment Agency (NEA).

As a result, Nee Soon GRC MP Louis Ng will file a motion in Parliament in Oct to address the issue, he said on Facebook on Sunday (6 Sep).


He doesn’t want a ban on smoking in HDB flats, but also wishes for a solution that’ll reduce harm to others.

Secondhand smoke in HDB flats

Smoking in one’s home isn’t banned. However, many smoke at their windows or balconies, causing the smoke to drift into other homes.

Cigarette ashes also scatter, sometimes on laundry and balconies, when they do so.

For those who don’t own an air-conditioner, closing the windows isn’t a viable long-term solution as Singapore can get very warm and humid.

It also does no favours for ventilation.

Possible solutions to reduce harm on others

Currently, the only solution is to advise smokers to not smoke at their windows.

Another is to dissuade smoking altogether, although a complete smoking ban is unlikely to happen overnight.

In 2018, several MPs, including Mr Ng, tried unsuccessfully to get smoking in homes banned.

The response they received was that smokers have the right of privacy to smoke at home.

One solution which doesn’t call for an outright ban is closing the windows and doors when one smokes.

Some reason that since the person smokes, they’re making a conscious choice and shouldn’t let the smoke enter other flats.

We already have smoking cabins outdoors, but these can be a challenge to install in residential estates.


Serious health issues with secondhand smoke

Secondhand smoke has potential ramifications, such as increasing the risk of lung cancer, stroke, heart disease, and asthma.

For lung cancer, the risk increases by at least a quarter, according to HealthHub.

Existing asthma suffers may also see their condition worsen.

48,020 cases of cancer could be linked to secondhand smoke in 2012, according to a study published on the Asian Pacific Journal of Cancer Prevention in 2019.

Many wish for smoking ban in HDB flats

Although this won’t happen overnight as smokers still have the right to smoke at home, many still wish for a smoking ban in HDB flats.

Regardless, here’s hoping that policymakers can solve the issue and come to a compromise if Mr Ng manages to speak about it in Parliament.

Do you think there can be a compromise between an outright ban and allowing smokers their rights? Let us know in the comments.

Featured image adapted from Facebook and Google Maps

Jonathan Yee

Jonathan is a bedroom headbanger. His Kobo is never far from him.

Recent Posts

Leong Mun Wai’s Facebook Post Misrepresented Facts & Cast Aspersions, Should’ve Debated In Parliament: Shanmugam

Mr Shanmugam said Mr Leong could've disagreed with him and debated in Parliament.

22 Mar 2023, 9:46 pm

HDB Flat Catches Fire 1 Day Before Ramadan, Family Safe & Welcomes Donations

Not the way anyone would want to begin the fasting month.

22 Mar 2023, 8:48 pm

S’pore Woman Buys S$265 AirPods Pro On Carousell, Device Falls Apart After Dropping Once

She first realised they were fake after taking them to iStudio for repairs.

22 Mar 2023, 8:32 pm

Farrer Park Mutton Soup Stall Closing After 35 Years, Elderly Hawkers Can’t Withstand Physical Toll

The elderly hawkers cited bodily pains and numbness in their fingers.

22 Mar 2023, 6:13 pm

Riders & Pillions Thrown Off Motorcycles After Collision On BKE, 4 People Conveyed To Hospital

Both motorcycles seemingly had pillion riders.

22 Mar 2023, 4:29 pm