383 People Died Of Secondhand Smoke In 2016, Louis Ng Wants Smoking Banned Near Windows

Nee Soon MP Louis Ng Calls For Smoking Ban At Windows & Balconies

As you’re chilling near your window, puffs of smoke end up wafting in and assault your senses.

You look up and realise that a neighbour is also enjoying their time relaxing at the window. The only difference is, there’s a cigarette in hand.

To smokers, the activity is largely gratifying. To others, it is a public health concern, especially secondhand smoke. This was what Nee Soon GRC MP Louis Ng sought to address in Parliament yesterday (5 Oct).


He is asking the government to consider banning smoking at windows and balconies of homes, so that this cuts down adverse effects of secondhand smoke on neighbours.

Louis Ng calls for smoking ban at HDBs & private apartments

According to The Straits Times, Mr Ng – who chairs the Sustainability & Environment Government Parliamentary Committee – said they are calling for the ban on residents in HDBs and private apartments.


He said 383 people had died from secondhand smoke in 2016.

In other words, that’s about “1 person dying every day”.

He added that many residents had complained to him about secondhand smoke when it drifts into their homes from neighbours upstairs.

Babies cry, and windows have to shut, which ends up cutting off proper ventilation.

Use cameras to catch culprits

Mr Ng said the ban is possible if government agencies makes use of technology available.

According to Channel NewsAsia (CNA), he said authorities can consider using:

  • Optical cameras – used to catch high-rise littering – to capture people tossing cigarette butts out of windows
  • Thermal surveillance cameras to catch residents smoking at forbidden premises, like common corridors.

With such technology readily available, all they need right now is a law to enforce the ban.

Government says law is “highly intrusive”

In response to Mr Ng’s adjournment motion, Amy Khor – who is Senior Minister of State for Sustainability and the Environment said such a law is “highly intrusive”.

TODAY Online reports that the ban wouldn’t be effective as it is difficult to enforce.

Ms Khor explains why:

  • Smoking offence isn’t straightforward — cameras must capture them in the act, or holding a cigarette as proof
  • Smokers can easily conceal themselves to avoid detection
  • Cameras need to be installed at strategic points i.e. aiming it directly into homes, but this is invasion of privacy

Instil greater social responsibility instead

It looks like the government is working on long-term solutions instead, which involves instilling greater sense of social responsibility, reports The Straits Times.

Ms Khor also said they will need to look at how they can encourage neighbours to have “productive conversations” when faced with difficult situations.

The government will also work with agencies to look at how they can better address disputes by reviewing current dispute management guidelines.

Louis Ng says this is a public health crisis, not dispute issue

Mr Ng, however, thinks that this is more than a neighbourly dispute issue, and the government should view secondhand smoke as a public health crisis instead.


Policies may come out differently if they view the issue as one that’s of grave concern, he said in TODAY Online’s report.

This didn’t go down well with Ms Khor, who responded by saying that there are laws already in place to ban smoking in common areas and public spaces — 32,000 places, to be exact.

She insisted that using cameras to catch those smoking in the privacy of their homes is highly difficult.

Hope authorities can continue to find a way

Dealing with secondhand smoke at home is difficult, but it looks like there are significant challenges in tackling the issue as well.

We hope the government can continue to explore ways to look out for residents, who are seeking protection from secondhand smoke — especially when it doesn’t come from their own household.

Have news you must share? Get in touch with us via email at

Featured image adapted from Lockbox Living.

Amanda Yeap

Amanda is obsessed with wet tissues, especially 100% antibacterial bamboo organic ones. She also likes to use them to chope tables at eateries.

Recent Posts

S’porean Singer Makes It To Top 50 In Australian Idol, Previously Performed At NDP 2014

His dad initially wanted him to be a doctor.

8 Feb 2023, 5:53 pm

Father In China Threatens Son With Samurai Sword Over Poor Test Performance, Accidentally Kills Him

His son's last words were, "Dad, I'm studying hard!"

8 Feb 2023, 5:39 pm

Turkish Embassy In S’pore Seeks Donations For Earthquake Victims, Winter Clothes Needed

They are looking for winter clothes for both adults and children.

8 Feb 2023, 4:59 pm

Lucky Plaza Chicken Rice Stall With ‘Grumpy’ Seller Sees Long Queue, Customers Buy Multiple Packets

Despite the polarising reputation, customers are lining up for the chicken rice.

8 Feb 2023, 3:35 pm