On 16 Nov 1974, 29-year-old Mohamed Azad s/o Mohamed Hussein was brutally killed with multiple blows to his head by a chopper.
However, his death was not discovered until 21 Nov 1974, when a gunnysack containing his decomposing body was found floating in the Kallang Basin.
Police quickly classified the case as murder.
Days later, a surprising suspect emerged — his fiancée’s father, who was opposed to his daughter’s relationship with the victim.
On 21 Nov 1974, a senior police officer at the Marine Police Headquarters spotted a gunnysack floating near the jetty.
He and his colleague decided to go down the water to find out what it contained.
After fishing the sack out of the water, they found it sewn shut except for a hole where a boot was sticking out.
Upon opening it, they found another sewn-up gunnysack, which ended up containing Mr Azad’s body wrapped in a polythene bag.
Mr Azad. Source: The Straits Times via NewspaperSG
He had a gaping wound on his head, and his hands and legs were tied together.
A pathologist later found that the deceased could have been dead for at least four days.
After inspecting the body, police went to Kandang Kerbau station, where a report about Mr Azad’s disappearance was lodged on 17 Nov 1974.
Mr Azad’s close friend said he was last seen leaving a friend’s house along Orchard Road on 16 Nov 1974.
He had told them he was meeting someone at Kerbau Road to collect a diary his fiancée, Ms Deva Kumari, reportedly owned.
“He left us at about 3.40pm, and we saw him taking a taxi,” his friend said. “That was the last we saw of him.”
On 21 Nov 1974, authorities investigated the home of 59-year-old Nadarajah Govindasamy, Ms Deva’s father, whom Mr Azad had met right before he disappeared.
An establishment in Kerbau Road. Image courtesy of National Archives Singapore. For illustration purposes only.
They found bloodstains in various parts of Nadarajah’s house, including on the floor of a staircase, a store-room entrance and wall, and a gas cooker.
Investigators also found blood in his car and seized a bloodstained chopper at the bottom of a flight of stairs.
Authorities arrested Nadarajah, and he was charged with Mr Azad’s murder on 23 Nov 1974.
He was suspected of having killed Mr Azad at around 4.40pm on 16 Nov 1974.
Nadarajah, the owner of a transport company, began trial at the High Court on 11 Aug 1975.
The prosecution claimed he opposed his daughter and Mr Azad’s relationship and lured the victim using his daughter’s diary, which allegedly contained Ms Deva’s feelings towards the victim.
On the day of the incident, Ms Deva had told the victim not to meet her father, saying she never kept such a diary.
However, Mr Azad did not heed her warning and unknowingly walked into his death.
Deputy Public Prosecutor (DPP) Lawrence Ang said in his opening remarks:
For reasons which perhaps only this 59-year-old father can establish, Azad met his death in circumstances that must have been both grisly and gory, for there were a total of seven fatal wounds on his head and four others at the back, all executed with extreme force.
When Mr Azad did not show up to dinner with Ms Deva and their friends at 8pm, they began searching for him.
They even went to Nadarajah’s home, but he calmly claimed that the deceased had left at 5pm after collecting a book titled ‘What is Religion?’.
Ms Deva had reportedly left her father’s home in 1970 due to constant arguments. However, she said she still visited her family on weekends.
In 1972, she and Mr Azad began steadily seeing each other. They got along well despite religious differences, being Hindu and Muslim, respectively.
Source: The Straits Times via NewspaperSG
However, their relationship did not go unnoticed by the father, who reportedly opposed it.
On the third day of her father’s trial, Ms Deva told the High Court that she and Mr Azad had plans to get married without her parents’ knowledge.
She also shared that they became engaged sometime in 1972, but only their two close friends knew about it.
In a bid to reduce his charge to culpable homicide, the accused’s counsel claimed that Mr Azad had provoked Nadarajah.
They said Mr Azad had gone to the accused’s home to pick up the aforementioned book.
While he was there, they chatted about Ms Deva, which eventually led to an argument.
Nadarajah said he became infuriated when Mr Azad allegedly accused him of being a bad father and told him he was going to marry his daughter.
Source: The Straits Times via NewspaperSG
“He… said that my daughter, because of my neglect, could have slept with many men and even he could have and can sleep with her,” he claimed.
The suspect said this further angered him, and the two began exchanging blows.
“He fell near the staircase at the kitchen,” he recalled. “The chopper was there within my reach and I picked it up in rage and struck him.”
Nadarajah said he did not know how he committed the act. He also claimed he felt confused and disturbed after dumping Mr Azad’s body into a canal on Hertford Road.
On 20 Aug 1975, Nadarajah was found guilty and sentenced to death for the “senseless and brutal murder” of Mr Azad.
The prosecution said the accused had omitted parts of the story. They also cited the witnesses’ statements that he had been calm when they initially questioned him about Azad’s whereabouts.
Additionally, DPP Ang believed that Azad had not provoked Nadarajah and argued that the accused had lured Azad with his daughter’s “diary”.
Nadarajah appealed his death sentence, but his request was dismissed on 19 Feb 1976.
His death row plea for leave to appeal was also rejected by the Privy Council in London on 23 July 1976.
On 28 Jan 1977, 60-year-old Nadarajah was hanged at Changi Prison.
Ms Deva was not present when her father was sentenced to death, saying she could not bring herself to go to court.
She said the news shocked her, despite having prepared for the worst.
Additionally, she told reporters she wasn’t sure if she should visit him in prison, saying she felt sorry for her father but felt “confused” about the entire situation.
Source: The Straits Times via NewspaperSG
“I really don’t know what to do now,” she expressed.
However, she said she would try her best to look after her mother and sister, feeling it had become her duty.
When Nadarajah’s appeal was dismissed, Ms Deva was understood to be in Europe, The Straits Times reported.
In Nov 2004, when Singaporean crime show True Files re-enacted the case, Nadarajah’s former lawyer N. Ganesan reportedly said he was unaware of the family’s whereabouts and believed Ms Deva had left the country.
Also read: This day 32 years ago: The failed shooting at Holland Village, and the gunman who vanished
Have news you must share? Get in touch with us via email at news@mustsharenews.com.
Featured image adapted from The Straits Times via NewspaperSG.