Environment

Tree Near Toa Payoh Carpark Collapses Suddenly, 6 Cars & 6 Motorcycles Damaged

Tree Falls On Toa Payoh Carpark Vehicles, Several Seen With Major Damage

Singapore’s known for being a garden city, and that’s partly because we have large trees almost everywhere.

They help to shelter us from the sun and rain, and break up the concrete jungle with some greenery.

But sometimes, the trees themselves break up, and end up causing havoc below. Take this tree that used to cover a Toa Payoh open-air carpark.

Source

It suddenly collapsed directly on top of several parked vehicles, causing damage to 6 cars and 6 motorcycles.

No one injured, only vehicles

The usual peace and quiet of a Sunday (13 Dec) morning was shattered by the incident, which according to 8World News, took place at the carpark in front of Block 68, Toa Payoh Lorong 5.

While 6 cars and 6 motorcycles were crushed, it’s fortunate that no one was injured.

Source

However, the owners of the affected vehicles probably won’t feel so fortunate.

Tree fell near Chee Soon Juan’s residence

Singapore Democratic Party (SDP) chief Chee Soon Juan posted on Facebook about the incident soon after it occurred, saying it happened near his residence.

 

Source

While Dr Chee has contested in Bukit Batok in 2 elections, he actually lives with his family in a flat in Toa Payoh.

He said one unfortunate car was completely covered by the falling branches.

Source

Speculating that the tree must have been old and rotten inside, he added that a couple of similar incidents had occurred in the estate.

Another resident’s motorcycle wrecked

Another resident, Mr Mohd Norman, knows all too well about that.

His motorcycle was wrecked in Sunday’s incident, 6 months after his car’s windscreen was smashed by a falling branch.

Source

He posted on Facebook about his woes shortly after the latest episode.

Source

He said it happened at 7am plus, just as he was about to leave for work.

Since his vehicles have been damaged twice by trees, he questioned whether he should have to pay for the damages out of his own pocket, since it’s not his responsibility to take care of trees in his estate.

Resident paid $100 in damages after previous incident

Mr Mohd Norman told 8 World that in the first incident on 29 Jun, he found his car’s rear windscreen broken by a tree branch.

The 39-year-old firefighter said at that time, his car was the only vehicle to suffer damages, which he paid $100 to repair after claiming part of the cost from his insurance.

On Sunday (13 Dec), at least he now had company in his misery.

Source

As far as he knows, the weather was fine before both incidents, with no heavy rain or strong wind detected.

Town Council has consulted a tree expert

Bishan-Toa Payoh Town Council told 8 World that they’ve consulted an arboriculturist, i.e. a tree expert, over the matter.

A report is being awaited, so we should be looking forward to an update.

Source

However, Mr Mohd Norman wasn’t too satisfied with the Town Council’s reply to him after the first incident, he told 8 World.

According to him, they rejected his claim of compensation, blaming a lack of manpower due to the Covid-19 pandemic for a lapse in tree maintenance work.

This time round, he’s written to the Town Council again over the damage to his motorcycle.

From what he’s observed, there’s damage to the body, handlebars and headlights.

After he sends the bike for repairs on Monday (14 Dec), he’ll know whether the engine is also damaged.

One car’s roof & windshield caved in

According to photos posted by the SG Road Vigilante Facebook group, a black car was damaged so badly that its roof and windshield had completely caved in.

Source

Also, the front bonnet was smashed, and even its licence plate had gone askew.

It’s uncertain whether such widespread damage can be repaired, and if so, how much it would cost.

Not of the fault of the vehicle owners

We shudder to think what would’ve happened if somebody was in the tree’s path as it collapsed, like the poor woman who was killed by a falling tree at the Botanic Gardens in 2017.

We sympathise with the owners of the vehicles affected, as it’s simply not their fault.

Hopefully, our manpower situation improves soon, so the trees across Singapore can be better maintained and such incidents don’t happen again.

Have news you must share? Get in touch with us via email at hello@mustsharenews.com.

Featured images adapted from Facebook and Facebook.

Jeremy Lee

Analog person making do with a digital world.

Recent Posts

About 20 cyclists caught for riding in large groups & other offences: LTA

Those who break the rules on group size can be fined S$150 each.

7 May 2024, 1:00 am

OSIM apologises & changes displays after netizens say its Mother’s Day campaign ‘recommends domestic violence’

A netizen also questioned the need to body shame mothers, who sacrificed their waistlines to…

6 May 2024, 10:49 pm

‘I Not Stupid 3’ will be released on 6 June, 22 years after first movie

The young cast will go through familiar stressful childhood experiences like collecting exam results.

6 May 2024, 9:41 pm

All Time Low cancels S’pore concert halfway after lead singer falls ill, fans unhappy with compensation

Fans took to the concert promoter’s comment section to voice their displeasure.

6 May 2024, 6:57 pm

68 HDB flats resold for at least S$1M in April, most were in Kallang-Whampoa area

The most expensive resale flat in April was a S$1.438 million 5-room flat in Toa…

6 May 2024, 6:51 pm

Chan Chun Sing helping Thambi Magazine Store owner find new location at Holland Village

Maybe there's hope yet for the iconic newsstand.

6 May 2024, 5:59 pm