S’pore Relief Teacher Dismissed For Not ‘Proactively’ Stopping Students’ Fight, Hopes School Will Handle Situation Better

Relief Teacher Allegedly Dismissed By School Over Phone Call After Fight In Class

Teachers often wear multiple hats, including that of a disciplinarian for students at school. And while this heavy responsibility falls on full-time teachers, the same is often expected of relief teachers.

Source: Ministry of Education on Facebook. For illustration purposes only.

Recently, Celine – a relief teacher – shared that a minor fight had happened in the class she was teaching, at an undisclosed secondary school in the West of Singapore.

The next day, she reportedly got a call from the school’s discipline mistress who said her response to the fight was “unprofessional” as she was not being “proactive”.

Celine was then informed that the school had decided to terminate her contract.

She later took to Instagram to share about the incident, hoping that the school would have greater respect for relief teachers like her and will better handle such situations.

Relief teacher dismissed by school for not being “proactive” during fight in sec 1 class

In an Instagram post shared on Saturday (3 Oct), Celine shared that she has been relief teaching Math and Science at the particular school for a year.

Things were apparently smooth-sailing until 21 Sep when a “minor fight” broke out at a secondary 1 class she was teaching.

Source: Instagram

Celine shared that she reprimanded the students and told them to stop the fight. When the students broke apart, she went over to check and question them about the scuffle.

She also told the class chairperson to inform their form teacher about the incident. In total, the entire incident started and ended within less than five minutes.

However, the next day, she received a call from the discipline mistress asking about the fight. She refers to the discipline mistress as ‘Ms A’ in her post.


After Celine recounted the incident, Ms A responded by saying that she did not take action, based on what was seen on the CCTV footage.

Celine pointed out that she was seated when the fight broke out and that the CCTV did not capture sound.

Ms A further claimed that Celine was “unprofessional” and not “proactive”. Hence, the “school leaders” decided to terminate her contract.

“It is also hard for them to explain to the parents”, she said.

Request for in-person meeting not granted

The school said that the reason for Celine’s dismissal was due to her response to the situation.

However, Celine shared in her post that relief teachers are not trained to handle such situation and that there is no SOPs communicated to them on how to handle such situations.

Celine shared that she had apologised on her end for not handling the situation in the best possible way.

Source: Instagram

Nonetheless, Celine felt that the school was mishandling things, especially for dismissing her via a phone call without hearing her out in person.

After the call, Celine requested a meeting to iron things out. But even after a week, her request has yet to be granted.

On the other hand, the school followed up with the affected students’ parents within less than a day.

To date, the school has not gotten back to her and she was removed from the school chat without notice on 30 Sep.

Dismissed relief teacher felt situation was mishandled

Celine felt the school was being disrespectful of their temporary staff.

She implied that it was ironic for the school to punish her for her supposed “unprofessionalism” while dismissing her without a legitimate reason over a phone call.

On the other hand, Celine felt that if the same had happened with the class’ form teacher,  it would be unlikely for the school to have dismissed them.

Taking an objective view of things, Celine said the school seemed to be taking the “easy way out” by using her as a scapegoat.

She also felt that it was unfair for the blame to be put on her for something that was beyond her control. Furthermore, she added that she had ensured that the incident was reported to the school.

Ending the post, Celine said that she’s sharing the incident not because of her dismissal, but over how she felt the incident was mishandled.

Source: Instagram

As a school and as educators that advocate for values like respect and empathy, she said that they “failed to walk the talk”.

Have news you must share? Get in touch with us via email at

Featured image adapted from Ministry of Education on Facebook and Instagram. For illustration purposes only. 

Sabrina Seng

Sabrina is always facing some form of existential crisis but other than that, she's pretty chill.

Recent Posts

New hawker centre opens in Bukit Batok West in 2025, will have 22 food stalls

A tender for its operator was called on 28 Feb.

2 Mar 2024, 12:35 am

More thundery showers expected in 1st half of March, 35°C temperatures on a few days

The second week of March may see 35°C temperatures when there is less cloud coverage.

1 Mar 2024, 10:50 pm

Malnourished & mistreated: Cats in Geylang cat café rescued after reports of neglect

SPCA had observed "concerning" signs of compromised welfare.

1 Mar 2024, 5:36 pm

S’porean women fall victim to hate crime in Ireland, one had Coke can thrown at head

One of the Irish boys used a derogatory slang for Asians against the woman at…

1 Mar 2024, 5:04 pm

Cyclist jailed for knocking down 80-year-old woman outside Bedok coffeeshop before riding off

The accused also rebuked the victim for not looking out.

1 Mar 2024, 4:01 pm