Latest News

YouTuber Calls Tamil ‘Indian Language’ In S’pore Travel Guide, S’poreans Point Out Inaccuracies

Travel YouTuber Gets Flak For Inaccuracies In Singapore Guide Video

Before we embark on our travels, many of us will do our research, including watching video guides on our destination countries.

Oftentimes, we trust the information provided in these videos to be accurate, but this might not always be true.

On 1 Feb, Yellow Productions Travel Guides shared a video titled ‘What You Need To Know Before Visiting Singapore!’ on Facebook.

However, the video contained quite a few inaccuracies. For example, it described Singlish as a mix of English and Chinese and referred to Tamil as an ‘Indian language’.

Singaporeans soon flocked to the video’s comment section to point out these mistakes.

YouTuber calls Tamil ‘an Indian language’

On 1 Feb, Yellow Productions Travel Guides posted a Facebook video about things to know before visiting Singapore.

In the first section, American YouTuber Chris Raney, who runs the channel, talks about the exchange rate and the importance of having cash on hand.

Source

He then says that Singapore is still very much cash-based. According to him, cash is needed at hawker centres and sometimes taxis.

 

Raney then talks about the laws in Singapore, stressing that chewing gum is illegal. Hence, he asked travellers not to bring it into the country.

After a brief description of our tropical weather, Raney moves on to the languages of Singapore.

He shares that Singapore has 4 official languages. While elaborating, he makes the mistake of saying the languages are “English, Mandarin, Malay, and an Indian language”.

Source

Raney says that “the official, official language is English”.

Source

He then describes Singlish as adding Chinese words into English as well as adding extra words for emphasis.

Singaporeans point out inaccuracies in travel guide

At the time of writing, the video has garnered over 1,400 shares. Many Singaporeans took to the comment section to point out the inaccuracies in Raney’s video.

Many criticised how he referred to Tamil as an ‘Indian language’.

Source

Netizens also noted that our national language – or in Raney’s words ‘official, official language’ – is actually Malay, not English.

Source

Some also took issue that the video says Singlish is only a mix of English and Chinese. This netizen noted that it actually includes all 4 official languages.

Source

Besides the language section, one netizen also corrected that one can chew gum in Singapore. Only the sale of chewing gum is illegal.

Source

Likely to be an old video

While some of the misinformation in the travel guide comes down to a lack of research, another possible reason for the inaccuracies could be that it is outdated, as pointed out by some netizens.

A quick search through Yellow Productions Travel Guides’ YouTube channel shows that Raney has uploaded 18 videos in Singapore.

Some were shot from as far as 8 years back. The most recent videos of Singapore were filmed 5 years ago in 2017.

The videos filmed in 2017 show Raney donning the same orange shirt he was wearing in the travel guide.

Source

One particular video, titled ‘Singapore Travel Tips: 6 Things to Know Before You Go’, also echoes a lot of the same information included in the Facebook video.

Hope Raney will be receptive to feedback

Such misinformation could give his global audience the wrong impression of Singapore.

With a strong following of over 99,000 users on Facebook and 239,000 subscribers on YouTube, many perhaps expected Yellow Productions Travel Guides to do better.

Hopefully, Raney will be receptive to the feedback he is getting and do his due diligence in future.

Have news you must share? Get in touch with us via email at news@mustsharenews.com.

Featured image adapted from Yellow Productions Travel Guides on Facebook.

Sabrina Seng

Sabrina is always facing some form of existential crisis but other than that, she's pretty chill.

Recent Posts

Wall Street Journal retrenches 8 staff in S’pore & HK offices, will move Asia HQ here

"It is difficult to say goodbye," said WSJ editor-in-chief Emma Tucker.

4 May 2024, 1:34 am

43-year-old ex-SAF officer dies after collapsing at work, reportedly suffered cardiac arrest

He had always been strong and healthy and his family had no history of heart…

4 May 2024, 12:15 am

Residents creeped out by Freddy Krueger collectible hung outside Boon Lay HDB flat

The owner of the portrait has since taken it down to avoid disturbing neighbours.

3 May 2024, 9:41 pm

Tickets for S’pore vs South Korea World Cup qualifier now on sale from S$10

The match will be held on 6 June at the National Stadium.

3 May 2024, 6:30 pm

S’pore delivery man gets into dispute with police officer, demands officer’s ID & refuses to give his

He accused the officer of being "scared" of him as well.

3 May 2024, 6:27 pm

HSA finds potent steroids in 3 health products, warns public against consuming them

Consumption of the health products can have severe side effects.

3 May 2024, 6:27 pm