KTPH says no lapse in care for 52-year-old patient who died, but daughter questions alleged 45-min gap

Daughter of KTPH patient asks why family was told that his heart stopped at some point over 45 mins

Khoo Teck Puat Hospital (KTPH) has said that no lapse in care was given to a 52-year-old patient who died in September, after his daughter “Kiinnoo Tohh” questioned the care he was provided in a Facebook post.

However, the daughter responded that her family was told by a doctor that his heart had stopped “at any point” over a 45-minute period, and asked why they were not told that he was assisted to the toilet during that time.

Source: Kiinnoo Tohh on Facebook

Patient admitted to KTPH due to fever

In her post on Tuesday (17 Nov), Ms Toh said her father Toh Ching Siong was admitted to KTPH on 24 Sept after suffering from fever for eight days.

They were allegedly told that he would not be given antibiotics immediately as he was an alcoholic and had to wait till the alcohol in his system was withdrawn.

He later started hallucinating due to alcohol withdrawal, and the family was allegedly told that this was normal.

He was placed under sedation and was last seen conscious and communicative at about 10pm on 26 Sept, she noted.

Patient allegedly was without a heartbeat anytime over a 45-min period

At about 3am on 27 Sept, Ms Toh said the hospital called saying Mr Toh had suffered a cardiac arrest and was in the Intensive Care Unit (ICU).

She claimed none of the medical team could give a definitive answer as to when his heart had stopped, saying:

We were informed that the last time his blood pressure was checked was approximately 1.30am, and the next time he was discovered unresponsive and not breathing was around 2.15am.

This was a 45-min interval in which he could have been without a heartbeat “for anywhere between one minute and 45 minutes”, she noted.

Source: Kiinnoo Tohh on Facebook

Daughter claims KTPH doctor made insensitive remark

Ms Toh was then allegedly told that it took the medical team about 14 mins to resuscitate her father, who then stayed for about a week in the ICU as he was still unconcious.

He was later diagnosed with severe brain damage associated with a prolonged lack of oxygen. The family was also told that multiple organs were failing, she said.

She took issue with what a doctor allegedly said at the time, that “it would be better” if her father did not wake up as he would likely be in a vegetative state.

“How insensitive can such a remark be towards a family desperately hoping for their loved one to survive?” she asked.

She also claimed that doctors “repeatedly emphasised” that her father would not regain consciousness.

Eventually, the family decided to take Mr Toh off the ventilator on 4 Oct, and he passed away about four hours later at the age of 52.

Source: Kiinnoo Tohh on Facebook

Daughter demands explanation from KTPH

Ms Toh demanded “a thorough, transparent investigation” and “a detailed written explanation” from KTPH, including:

  • The medical justification for delaying antibiotics
  • The sedation administered
  • The monitoring arrangements throughout the night
  • The observations documented between 1.30am and 2.15am, and why nobody could establish when his cardiac arrest began
  • Whether his severe brain damage and organ failure could have been prevented or reduced through earlier intervention

“I refuse to accept that a 45-minute gap between observations can simply be brushed aside without a proper explanation, especially when the patient subsequently suffered a cardiac arrest and irreversible injuries,” she said.

KTPH refutes daughter’s claims on antibiotics & 45-min lapse

In a Facebook post of its own on Friday (20 Nov), KTPH refuted Ms Toh’s claim that the doctor had declined to administer antibiotics to the patient due to the presence of alcohol in his system.

A review found that the medical team administered antibiotics to the patient on the same day he was admitted, the hospital said.

As for the alleged 45-min lapse between 1.30am and 2.15am, this did not exist, according to a review of CCTV footage, KTPH noted.

The footage showed that a nurse assisted Mr Toh to the toilet at 1.40am and assisted back to his bed at 1.56am, it added.

However, he was found unresponsive by a staff at 2.15am.

Source: Google Maps

KTPH expresses regret if remarks were insensitive

KTPH said that while Mr Toh was in ICU, the ICU explained his prognosis and the seriousness of his brain injury to the family.

“They also discussed quality of life and the available care options with the family,” it noted, adding:

The medical information and care options conveyed by our ICU doctor were clinically appropriate for the patient’s condition and prognosis at the time.

However, KTPH expressed regret and apologised if the remarks had “come across as insensitive” during that difficult period.

KTPH says no lapse in care to patient

KTPH maintained that there was “no lapse in the care” rendered to Mr Toh throughout his stay, with its healthcare workers doing their very best.

However, the family did not raise unresolved issues when its care team engaged them in a conference and when a patient experience officer and medical social worker stepped in to offer emotional support, it said.

The hospital did not hear further updates from the family until the Facebook post on 17 Nov, and invited them to get in touch as soon as possible.

Family allegedly not previously told that patient was helped to the toilet

Ms Toh replied to KTPH in two Facebook posts on Saturday (21 Nov), saying that the family was not informed that Mr Toh was assisted to the toilet at 1.40am and back to his bed at 1.56am.

She questioned why this was so, asking:

Why was this information never communicated to us when we questioned your doctors on the very first day?… Why were we repeatedly told that his last check was at 1.30am? Why does the timeline provided in your public statement differ from what your doctor personally told our family?

She pointed out that it was the doctor who told them that her father was last checked about 1.30am before being found unresponsive at 2.15am, adding:

We did not fabricate information, make up stories, or deliberately spread false accusations. We shared what we personally heard and understood from the medical staff, with multiple family members present as witnesses.

Daughter asks why family not told that antibiotics given upon admission

On the antibiotics, Ms Toh claimed that the nurses and doctors had repeatedly told them that they could not administer antibiotics because there was still alcohol in his system.

“If antibiotics were indeed administered on the day of admission, why was this not clearly communicated to us? Why were we repeatedly given explanations that led us to understand otherwise?” she asked.

The family “did not invent” this explanation and has “absolutely no reason” to fabricate such information, she added.

Source: Kiinnoo Tohh on Facebook

Daughter says family repeatedly questioned doctors

While Ms Toh was deeply grateful to the ICU nurses for their “efforts, kindness and dedication”, she was concerned about the events leading up to his cardiac arrest and the explanations provided by the medical team, she said.

She explained that the family did not raise unresolved issues during the family conference as they had “already repeatedly questioned” the doctors from the first day but allegedly never given a satisfactory explanation.

She emphasised that they were allegedly told that “nobody could determine exactly when his heart stopped beating” during that 45-min period.

Daughter requests CCTV & records be made available for review

Thus, Ms Toh requested that relevant CCTV footage and records be preserved and made available for independent review.

This is because the information being presented publicly is “different” from what the family was told, she claimed.

The family is also prepared to identify the medical staff who gave us the information they shared, she said.

They are “currently waiting for the hospital to contact us regarding the conference”, she added.

Also read: CGH Lung Cancer Patient Passes Away Due To Delayed Diagnosis, Family Awarded $326K In Damages

CGH Lung Cancer Patient Passes Away Due To Delayed Diagnosis, Family Awarded $326K In Damages

Have news you must share? Get in touch with us via email at news@mustsharenews.com.

Featured image adapted from Kiinnoo Tohh on Facebook.